WHAT KIND OF FOOD DOES PENELOPE SERVE?
Heartwarming comfort food just like your mom used to make,
if your mom was spending her summers out in Montauk surfing, knitting, and eating lobster rolls.
HAVE YOU JUST HAD ONE OF THOSE DAYS?
We serve a carefully chosen list of craft and or local beers and ciders, along side an off-the-beaten-path selection of wines enjoyable to all. Throw in a splash of soju cocktails and you have the perfect end (or start) to any kind of day.
WHO'S THAT THERE BACK IN YOUR KITCHEN?
We are pleased and proud to have Chef Matthew O’Loughlin in the trenches with us; lending his skill, professionalism, and love to our cozy comfort menu. He and his team of highly trained worker bees are the lifeblood of our operation.
DO YOU TAKE RESERVATIONS?
We seat on a first come first serve basis.
Also, due to our cozy dining room, we are only able to seat complete parties during peak hours. Are you a nearby neighbor? Then download the Nowait app and you can add your name to our list when we’re running a wait.
CAN I BRING MY BABY?
Are they crying? No? Cool. We have a highchair for this individual.
MY NAME IS JIMMY FALLON + I’M HOPING TO PUT A PENELOPE COFFEE MUG ON MY "TONIGHT SHOW" DESK. HOW DO I MAKE THAT HAPPEN?
Not a problem, you can order one right here. And thanks, we’re big fans!